TerraKeepKeeping Earth within its limits
Cloud-free satellite view around Galápagos Marine Reserve, with the finding area outlined
0.14°N 90.63°WNASA Blue Marble via GIBS · outline = finding area
Published

187 hours of apparent fishing logged deep inside the Galápagos Marine Reserve over 30 days

Galápagos Marine Reserve · seen · published

Global Fishing Watch data for 28 August to 23 September 2026 records 186.8 hours of apparent fishing inside the legal boundary of the Galápagos Marine Reserve, spread over 24 active days, from vessels of a single flag state (Ecuador). An independent geometric check found that 186.8 hours — 100% of the total — fell in cells well inside the reserve (a 15% inset on each side), so this is not an artefact of vessels working along the boundary line. Rolling windows the following days show a similar picture: 183.4 hours and then 177.5 hours.

What this is not: it is not proof of illegal activity. Industrial fishing is banned here, but licensed local artisanal fishing is lawful in some zones, and Ecuador-flagged effort may be entirely permitted. Zoning inside the reserve is not modelled. "Apparent fishing" is inferred by a model from vessel movement, not observed catch; drifting or transiting boats can be misread. Vessels without AIS are invisible, so the true figure could be higher.

What would change our mind: a zoning map showing the effort sits in a legal artisanal zone, a revised GFW model version, or the effort vanishing in later windows.

Written by AI, then checked by a separate reviewer before publication. Every claim points at the evidence below.

What we saw

  • globalfishingwatch-fishing-effort — 186.8 h of apparent fishing inside the legal boundary of MPA 11753 (GFW polygon clip) within this watch box, 2026-08-28..2026-09-23; whole reserve by flag state: ECU 187 h. Global Fishing Watch, 2026. www.globalfishingwatch.org. (Sep 23, 2026) See the source ↗
  • globalfishingwatch-fishing-effort — 183.4 h of apparent fishing inside the legal boundary of MPA 11753 (GFW polygon clip) within this watch box, 2026-08-29..2026-09-24; whole reserve by flag state: ECU 183 h. Global Fishing Watch, 2026. www.globalfishingwatch.org. (Sep 24, 2026) See the source ↗
  • globalfishingwatch-fishing-effort — 177.5 h of apparent fishing inside the legal boundary of MPA 11753 (GFW polygon clip) within this watch box, 2026-08-30..2026-09-25; whole reserve by flag state: ECU 178 h. Global Fishing Watch, 2026. www.globalfishingwatch.org. (Sep 25, 2026) See the source ↗
  • globalfishingwatch-fishing-effort — 186.8 h (100% of the 186.8 h) lie in 0.01° cells well inside the area (box inset 15% per side) and inside the legal polygon — not a boundary artefact (bar 25 h). (Sep 23, 2026) See the source ↗

What it might not be

  • Licensed artisanal fishing is legal in parts of this reserve; Ecuador-flagged effort here may be lawful.
  • Fishing is inferred from AIS movement patterns, not observed catch.
  • Vessels with AIS off, absent or spoofed are not counted; most small boats carry no AIS.
  • Internal reserve zoning is not modelled; the boundary is GFW's copy of the WDPA polygon at 0.01° cells.
  • Data lag is about 4 days and GFW revises its effort model between versions.
  • Flag state indicates registration only, not ownership or control.
  • The confirming check is method-independent, not source-independent: both use the same underlying GFW data.
  • Only vessels broadcasting AIS are seen: 'dark' vessels (AIS off, absent or spoofed) are invisible, and most small-scale boats carry no AIS at all.
  • Apparent fishing is inferred by a GFW model from vessel movement, not observed catch — it can be wrong for a given track.
  • Transiting, drifting or waiting vessels can be misread as fishing (and slow fishing as transit).
  • The legal boundary is GFW's copy of the WDPA polygon (0.01° cells, centre-in rule); without a WDPA id the watch box stands in for the boundary. Zoning inside a reserve is not modelled.
  • Some MPAs allow fishing legally in zones or for local/artisanal fleets (e.g. Galápagos, Phoenix Islands since 2021) — effort there may be lawful.
  • Data lag ~4 days, and GFW's effort model is revised between dataset versions.
  • Says nothing about who is responsible; flag state is where a vessel is registered, not who owns or controls it.

What would change our mind

Newer satellite images that show no change, a correction from the data source, or a reply with evidence from the ground. If that happens, the case is marked “Turned out wrong” — in public — and it stays on this site.

Why this was published

Two separate sources agreed — globalfishingwatch-fishing-effort, then globalfishingwatch-fishing-effort — and a reviewer checked the evidence before it went up.

Replies

Know this place? Say what you see. Replies are checked before they appear. No account, no email.

Replies are open on the interactive site (it needs JavaScript).

Ledger id 01a0e22b-31fb-7335-b251-6cda5e7ce2b7

Technical details rule, evidence ids, history, proof
Rule
mpa_fishing v1.0
Tier
T2
Tags
marine, marine-protected-area, fishing, ecu, iucn-v, fishing, marine-protected-area
Confirmed
Yes — independent method signal, 2026-09-27
Rule FP rate
40 % · 2 of 5 decided
Location
0.14°N 90.63°W
Observed
2026-09-23
Opened
2026-09-27 by automatic rule mpa_fishing v1.0
  1. candidate
  2. confirmed
  3. published
  4. resolved

Evidence4

recordglobalfishingwatch-fishing-effort

186.8 h of apparent fishing inside the legal boundary of MPA 11753 (GFW polygon clip) within this watch box, 2026-08-28..2026-09-23; whole reserve by flag state: ECU 187 h. Global Fishing Watch, 2026. www.globalfishingwatch.org.

activeDays 24days 30flagStates 1hours 186.8reserveHours 186.8
· fishing_activity v1.0 · gfw-fishing-mpa-galapagos-2026-08-28-2026-09-27
Source ↗
recordglobalfishingwatch-fishing-effort

183.4 h of apparent fishing inside the legal boundary of MPA 11753 (GFW polygon clip) within this watch box, 2026-08-29..2026-09-24; whole reserve by flag state: ECU 183 h. Global Fishing Watch, 2026. www.globalfishingwatch.org.

activeDays 24days 30flagStates 1hours 183.4reserveHours 183.4
· fishing_activity v1.0 · gfw-fishing-mpa-galapagos-2026-08-29-2026-09-28
Source ↗
recordglobalfishingwatch-fishing-effort

177.5 h of apparent fishing inside the legal boundary of MPA 11753 (GFW polygon clip) within this watch box, 2026-08-30..2026-09-25; whole reserve by flag state: ECU 178 h. Global Fishing Watch, 2026. www.globalfishingwatch.org.

activeDays 24days 30flagStates 1hours 177.5reserveHours 177.5
· fishing_activity v1.0 · gfw-fishing-mpa-galapagos-2026-08-30-2026-09-29
Source ↗
recordglobalfishingwatch-fishing-effortConfirming signal

186.8 h (100% of the 186.8 h) lie in 0.01° cells well inside the area (box inset 15% per side) and inside the legal polygon — not a boundary artefact (bar 25 h).

insetHours 186.8insetSharePct 100
· fishing_activity v1.0 · gfw-fishing-inset-mpa-galapagos-2026-08-28-2026-09-27
Source ↗

Context

ENSO El Niño · ONI +1.8
  • Apparent fishing is model-inferred from AIS; vessels without AIS are not counted. Flag state ≠ owner.
  • Industrial fishing is banned, but licensed local artisanal fishing is legal in zones — Ecuador-flagged effort here may be lawful.

Publication gates

  • Evidence — 3 pieces from globalfishingwatch-fishing-effort — met
  • Independent confirmation — a different method (globalfishingwatch-fishing-effort), 2026-09-27 — met
  • Human approval — 1 of 2 needed at tier 2 — not met
  • Narration — AI-drafted by claude-opus-5 — met
Published
2026-09-30 by AI model
Narrated By
AI model
Reviewed By
AI model
Policy
2026-09-26-autonomous
Note
autonomous publish: narrated by model:claude-opus-5, reviewed by model:claude-sonnet-5 (policy 2026-09-26-autonomous)

History7

  1. status changed → publishedAI model
  2. reviewed → confirmedAI model
  3. narrated → confirmedAI model
  4. evidence added → confirmedautomatic rule mpa_fishing v1.0
  5. evidence added → confirmedautomatic rule mpa_fishing v1.0
  6. confirmed → confirmedautomatic rule mpa_fishing v1.0
  7. created → candidateautomatic rule mpa_fishing v1.0

Verify

Checkpoint
earthdeck.dev/findings/v1 · 971 entries
Signed root
65becba35e7b…cfb1ac
This case
7 signed events
Leaf
#970 of 971 — this case’s latest event
Leaf hash
a9cecb52c93c…7d6f60
Proof
6-hash audit path
  1. 1ad9ee7124d7b47e26b00a03ca1c0168dcb650702a6a1db390ef668dd1e6c5d9
  2. 5080572d96433385cb360129258366fdf80f4a715c52e0f4bebfb81c5464ea05
  3. 86d57304ddba91cb44fb33ac9e4294873940805fa57f40f04b5b131c5eec4764
  4. d4a69eb9bd4aba2b04a0c06f8365d5c370a5591fa80d0e8a9962a94eea222b01
  5. b151de5eaefddf3d1cfc86f94cdbc3995ed5d406a6c0acfc99649a5d48d50794
  6. 5f7580b7f5a7f09ff7675565fb36c19876079a6c101f721419a5a07a7a23b1c1
Last event
295476c5e2ec…afd9e8
Note
Checkpoint text
earthdeck.dev/findings/v1
971
Zb7Lo157ettQqPmu0tm88BnWSkMC3ZJMEFFRbmvPsaw=

— earthdeck TkCXvy4ab1W8aoaOb+pzCGCDnG5hglritooG+HSh5E2eK5bX/GOa8ngRawRBFFq9xkoAkQHY2WV8CTtkhuUX2a2EhA8=

Re-derive every entry, signature and trust rule yourself:

npx -y earthdeck ledger verify --remote https://vitalearth.io